The idea of The Great Gatsby as “The Great American
Novel” somewhat connects to what we believe is “American.” Undeniably, something about this book truly
embodies what we think represents America. This raises an important question: is the
definition of “American” truly uniform, or is it far more subjective than we
imagine it to be? It is certainly hard
to assess such a definition, since the answer lies within. That is, what is considered to be “American”
lies within each one of us on a subconscious level; we grasp it but cannot
fully explain it. The notion of “American”
being a subjective quality also pertains to the topic of immigration. Immigration has made America a literal
melting pot, where numerous cultures are diffused into one. This idea of a mixture means that each
American may not be individually representative of all of American culture, but
rather one part of the body, one ingredient in the pot. One cannot merely describe an archetypal
American because there really isn't one.
Perhaps “American” isn't what a person is but rather what a person
belongs to, a melting pot. Part of being
American is to not be American, but rather to be something else that is somehow
connected to America. In fact, many
immigrants were intent on not becoming American, but simply wanted to be in
America. Nonetheless, these people
became American, and their children embraced American culture even more than
they did. Is being in America synonymous
with being American? Perhaps the future
holds the answer; to quote The Melting
Pot, “the real American has not yet arrived. He is only in the Crucible…he will be the
fusion of all races.”
Dear Spencer, I have had a very similar thought but i had it more with the angle of in this book there happen a lot of illegal things. And as you point out your self this is supposed to be like a image of America. So does that mean that for something to be american there must be something illegal involved. And why would we want to something like that to be the image of America?
ReplyDeleteThere are definitely a number of illegal things that go on in this book, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it's what we want to be or what it has to be; rather, what makes the novel American is that it simply states what is. In writing the novel, Fitzgerald is simply exemplifying what America is like, and is in a way asking Americans if this is what they want to be.
DeleteMaybe it isn't so much a look or an ethnicity, and it certainly is subjective, however according to the novel (or the narrator Nick Carraway) it is closer to a state of mind. He often talks about the Americanism of Gatsby's resourcefulness, so maybe being American has something to do with being scrappy. This is what I got from Nick's point of view, I am not sure if I agree with it myself.
ReplyDeleteHey Spencer, I think what you had to say with immigration being a melting pot is definitely spot on. In modern day, the USA is so diverse because of how much immigration happened a long time ago. Today in schools, we have cultures from all around the world. Everyone being a single race would be a boring place to live in dont ya think!
ReplyDeletei agree with the fact that despite whether you don't want to be identified as American or not, by living in America legally, you are considered American.
ReplyDeleteNice job Spencer. The way you described how and what it means to be American while simultaneously saying its hard to describe is pretty ironic. But seriously, being American is such a hard thing to define and we've tried many times this year already to try to do so. I have a questino though. Many people do consider an stereotypical american to white blond hair blue eyes etc. Why do you think that may be, despite all the good points you made?
ReplyDeleteHm...I suppose that it's hard to completely erase stereotypes, but the answer to your question goes back to the subjectivity I mentioned. We get so wrapped up in trying to understand each other that we tend to create these mental images to restore mental order, to create the fixed definition for which we search. To me, it is this unnecessarily elaborate attempt to understand that ultimately leads to...well...misunderstanding.
DeleteI will simply add that you guys rock. It is great to see a proper conversation going on here!
ReplyDelete